Vital Sounds 2026, Quarter 4
Vital Sounds 2026, Quarter 4
The Fear-to-Profit Pipeline: Fear Inflation in Medical Liability, and What the Defense Side Can Do About It
November 5, 2026
The Fear-to-Profit Pipeline: Fear Inflation in Medical Liability, and What the Defense Side Can Do About It
November 5, 2026
By Tucker Poling, JD, CPCU
Executive Vice President and General Counsel
Understanding Fear Inflation in Medical Liability
A patient experiences a bad outcome, and a physician receives a threatening letter from a law firm. Suddenly, the doctor’s mind begins running through a series of “what if” scenarios: What if the case goes to trial? What if there’s a large verdict? What could it mean for my career and financial future?
Healthcare professionals aren’t the only ones who experience this uncertainty. Insurance carriers, claims professionals, and defense attorneys also feel the tug of fear of being on the wrong side of an excessive verdict. Fear inflation is the gap between those feelings and the actual risk. When a claim is priced against fear rather than merit, every dollar paid in the gap feeds the plaintiff litigation machine, raises costs, and reduces access to care.
The Fear-to-Profit Pipeline
How fear inflation feeds itself.
Five things feed the inflation gap:
1. The headlines and the money behind them.
Large verdicts attract attention, but the headlines rarely tell the whole story. Medical malpractice verdicts of $10 million or more have risen sharply in this decade [1]. Yet headlines often don’t report what happens afterwards – those verdicts are often reversed or greatly reduced. Excessive verdicts in the Midwest in recent years have followed this pattern: a $97 million Iowa verdict was reversed on appeal, and a $111 million Minnesota verdict was set aside as shockingly excessive.
The media, billboards, attorneys and mediators repeat the original verdict headlines, driving settlement demands higher to account for the perceived threat. Behind those headlines sits a $61.7 billion plaintiff litigation industry [2] that spent more than $2.5 billion on advertising in 2024 [3].
Plaintiff’s attorneys take their contingency fee, sometimes 40 percent or more, off the top of the injured person’s monetary recovery, with no step-down in the attorney’s cut as the recovery climbs into seven and eight figures. This structure provides an incentive for attorneys to swing for the fences rather than resolve claims reasonably. Their tactics may include high initial demands, inflating projected future costs, pointing to outlier verdicts, and holding out against reasonable offers while stoking fear and conflict within the defense team.
2. Intimidation tactics by plaintiff attorneys.
Some pre-trial tactics are designed to create personal fear and pressure for healthcare professionals. A policy-limits demand may come with an artificial deadline meant to force rushed decisions rather than objective analysis. A letter may threaten to pursue your personal assets, suggest that the defense attorney and insurer aren’t advocating for you, or recommend you seek “independent” advice from an attorney chosen by the plaintiff’s lawyer.
One AMA senior attorney accurately called tactics threatening a physician’s personal assets “very psychologically damaging” [4]. We should name them for what they are: psychological abuse intended to scare, bully, and coerce payment and put money in the attorney’s pocket. The tactic works on fear, not on the realistic likelihood of collection.
Utah addressed this issue in 2025 by prohibiting the collection of a malpractice judgment from a healthcare professional’s personal assets and barring pre-award allegations about those assets when used to coerce settlement [5]. The AMA published model state legislation carrying the same protection in August 2026 [6]. Kansas has not yet given its healthcare professionals these protections.
3. Manufactured damages.
The case we discussed in the Q1 2023 issue came with a demand of more than $50 million, most of it projected lifetime future care. Plaintiff life-care plans and projections have become a litigation product and a cottage industry. Their value to plaintiff attorneys is the size of the number. No Kansas statute keeps inflated projections from professional life care planning witnesses out of the jury room.
4. Tort reform hasn’t kept up with plaintiff litigation industry tactics.
The Kansas Supreme Court undermined the Kansas cap on non-economic damages in Hilburn v. Enerpipe Ltd. in 2019. The legislature has not yet moved to clarify or replace this critical bulwark against the excesses of the tort system (see our Q2 2024 issue).
A 2026 bill to bar plaintiff attorneys from inserting their own opinions on the economic value of noneconomic pain and suffering into jury trials passed the Senate but died in the House [7]. Contingency fee reform (guardrails limiting the portion of an injured person’s settlement or verdict a lawyer can take for themselves) was introduced in 2020 and 2021 but never advanced [8].
5. Defense-side fear, and what it costs.
Here is the fact many on the defense side do not like to say out loud. Many defense attorneys, health systems, insurance carriers, and claims professionals often hesitate to defend healthcare professionals through trial for fear of being on the wrong side of an excessive verdict.
Jury consultants have described “nuclear settlements” paid on behalf of defendants who “would rather pay their way out of trouble,” which the plaintiff bar notices and rewards with more lawsuits against those defendants [9]. Over the past few years, it has also become more challenging across the country to find defense attorneys willing to try difficult cases and willing to stand firm in the face of excess-verdict intimidation tactics.
The effects of these five factors can be seen in the numbers. Average medical professional liability claim payments have risen significantly since 2019. And for eleven straight years, medical liability insurers have paid out more in claims and expenses than they collected in premium [10]. When claims are resolved based on fear rather than evidence, the costs can extend throughout the healthcare system. Patients pay in higher costs, in tests they did not need due to defensive medicine, and in lost access when healthcare professionals retreat from high-risk work and underserved communities, as New Mexico learned after raising its damages caps. And in the end, plaintiff’s attorneys keep the profits, and society pays the bill.
One Tactic, Taken Apart: Understanding the Threat Letter
A policy-limits demand letter threatening to collect a judgment against the healthcare professional’s personal assets has gone from an occasional tactic used by the most combative plaintiff attorneys to a relatively routine aspect of the med mal playbook. It can combine several of the tactics discussed above: nuclear-verdict opportunism, the manufactured damages number, a disingenuous “bad-faith” setup aimed at the insurance carrier, and an attempt to drive a wedge between you and your defense team.
The letter arrives addressed to your lawyer but written in hopes it will reach you and cause a reaction. It may:
- Demand the full limits of your insurance policy limits, often by an arbitrary deadline.
- Threaten to pursue your personal assets if a verdict exceeds your coverage.
- Claim inaccurately that your lawyer isn’t advocating for you.
- Recommend that you hire an “independent” attorney, who just so happen to be plaintiff attorney friends or colleagues of the letter writer.
Divide and conquer: an attempt to undermine your defense team.
The plaintiff's attorney knows your attorney and carrier are the only things standing between him and a big settlement payday. The letter is built to separate you from your lawyer and your insurance carrier – the infrastructure of your defense.
The threats compared to reality.
Figure 2 shows the numbers: roughly half of one percent of claims end in a plaintiff’s verdict, and it’s exceptionally rare for defendants to pay anything personally. In more than 35 years of defending KAMMCO-insured healthcare professionals, no plaintiff attorney has collected a judgment from a KAMMCO insured’s personal assets.
A threatening letter is designed to create fear. Nothing in it is addressed to the merits or to realistically expected outcomes. Nevertheless, the intended damage to the defendant’s state of mind is often done, and the plaintiff attorney’s financial interests are served.
Where Malpractice Claims Actually End
How to Prepare and Respond to Intimidation Tactics
Preparation can help reduce the impact of a threatening letter. Knowing what to expect before one arrives makes it easier to respond thoughtfully rather than react out of fear.
A Prepared Team
You know the medicine and the medical record. Your KAMMCO team has assessed the evidence, researched the literature, reviewed the case with experts, and has read countless letters like it. The stock language and gaslighting in the letter is usually identical to other such letters received on a regular basis. Your defense lawyer has also seen the tactic many times before and should build the case assessment and plan around the evidence, not reaction to intimidation tactics. Don’t let the letter achieve the goal of knocking your defense of the steady course.
One Kansas defense lawyer’s written response to such a letter captured the ideal posture. He firmly responded that the case would be assessed on the merits and on the timeline of the defense investigation, expert assessment, and rational evaluation, not the plaintiff attorney’s threats or timelines. He also identified the letter’s ethically problematic[1] aspects, and made clear that the plaintiff’s attorney would never be permitted to give legal advice to the defendant or decide how, when, or what the defense lawyer communicates to his client.
[1] The Kansas Rule of Professional Conduct applicable to attorneys (“KRPC”), states, at Rule 4.2: “In representing a client, a lawyer shall not communicate about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows to be represented by another lawyer in the matter, unless the lawyer has the consent of the other lawyer or is authorized to do so by law or a court order.” KRPC 4.4(a): a lawyer “shall not use means that have no substantial purpose other than to embarrass, delay, or burden a third person.” The Kansas Supreme Court publicly censured a plaintiff’s lawyer whose limits demand crossed ethical lines (In re Pyle, 2004). Your lawyer must promptly tell you the substance of any settlement offer (KRPC 1.4, cmt. [1]), but nothing requires him/her to deliver the sender’s advice.
A Better Approach to Medical Professional Liability Claims
Fear inflation is deflated one claim at a time by refusing to let fear drive decisions and by refusing to be divided. The approach that does this is objective, reasonable, fair and strong.
Objective: Let Facts and Evidence Guide Decisions
Evaluate the claim on the medicine and the record. Assess realistic jury outcomes against actual experience and historical collective verdict ranges in the jurisdiction rather than overweighting exceptional possibilities. As in medicine, in litigation, when you hear hoofbeats in Kansas, expect a horse, not a zebra.
Anxiety is natural when outcomes are uncertain (as they always are in jury trials), but letting those feelings control the analysis is a choice. The letter is information about the sender’s motives, strategy, and sometimes a “tell” of their own fear of having their claims tested at trial; it does not change the evaluation of the case.
Reasonable: Be Fair to Everyone Involved
A reasonable approach is fair in every direction under the circumstances. It is fair to an injured patient whose claim is shown to be valid based on the objective medicine and evidence. Some claims of negligence are valid and should be resolved through reasonable compensation – that’s one of the purposes of insurance.
It is also fair to you as the defendant. You should have a voice in the evaluation, know that your interests are being considered, receive an honest conversation about any exposure, and have a team willing to stand up for you through trial even in a challenging case.
And it’s fair to the insurance carrier. When the evidence establishes negligence and harm, a reasonable settlement that reflects the damages shown is appropriate. A blank check that tracks the plaintiff attorney’s demands rather than the evidence is not.
Strong: Be Prepared to Defend the Case
A strong defense team includes an experienced team willing to take challenging but defensible cases to trial, even when defending a case costs more than settling it. KAMMCO is committed to this approach, as our President and CEO, Kurt Scott, describes in the video below.
KAMMCO: Built for Your Most Challenging Days
Standing up for healthcare professionals protects our insureds and helps address the rising societal costs of litigation. In the video below, Dr. Nicholas Brown, MD, who tried his case, describes the alternatives: settling is the quickest way out, but in a litigious society, it would mean never seeing the end of suits. Standing up for healthcare matters. It’s not always the easy choice, but it’s often the right thing to do.
Standing Behind Physicians When It Matters Most
Not Divided: Stand Together
The defendant, defense counsel, and the claims professional stand together, rooted in reason and values. In the video below, Val Gleason, RN, President and CEO of NMC Health, describes a difficult case that went to trial, with KAMMCO’s leadership in the courtroom every day, coaching and supporting the hospital’s staff. You will never stand alone.
A Partnership That Goes Beyond Policy
Standing Your Ground, Together
Tort reform protects the justice system and society. An objective, reasonable, fair and strong approach to medical professional liability claims protects individual healthcare professionals. We need both.
The claim we discussed in the Q1 2023 issue involved many of the tactics described in this article: a sky-high claim for more than $50 million, a warning that a verdict would far exceed the insured’s coverage, and saber-rattling about a huge verdict as trial approached. Two co-defendants settled. The KAMMCO-insured physician and defense team held. The case was dismissed weeks before trial with no payment, no report to the licensing board, and no report to the National Practitioner Data Bank.
The litigation climate has become even more challenging since then, but the lesson remains the same: fear should not replace facts when evaluating a medical liability claim. Standing up for healthcare professionals requires an objective, reasonable, and strong defense — and a commitment to working together.
At KAMMCO, our commitment is straightforward: You will never stand alone.
Sources
- TransRe large-verdict data, as reported in Gallegos A. Mega malpractice verdicts against physicians on the rise. Medscape Medical News, February 2, 2024 (57 verdicts of $10 million or more in 2023, the most on record; between 34 and 52 a year from 2012 to 2022).
- IBISWorld, Personal Injury Lawyers & Attorneys in the US, 2025 (industry value about $61.7 billion).
- American Tort Reform Association, Legal Services Advertising in the United States, 2020-2024 (March 2025): more than $2.5 billion on 26.9 million ads in 2024.
- American Medical Association. Why medical malpractice awards are on the rise. AMA News Wire, January 2, 2026.
- Utah Code 78B-3-405.5(4), (5), enacted by H.B. 503, Laws of Utah 2025, ch. 503, effective May 7, 2025.
- American Medical Association Advocacy Resource Center. Model bill: Medical Liability Reform Act (2026), Section 9 (threats or actions against personal assets prohibited), posted August 17, 2026, implementing AMA House of Delegates Resolution 201 (I-25).
- Kansas Senate Bill 413 (2026), prohibiting counsel from suggesting an amount of damages for noneconomic loss in civil actions; passed the Senate 29-11 on February 18, 2026; died in House committee, April 27, 2026.
- Kansas Senate Bill 446 (2020) and Senate Bill 151 (2021), enacting limitations on contingency fee agreements in certain civil actions; each died in the Senate Judiciary Committee without a hearing (May 21, 2020; May 23, 2022).
- Courtroom Sciences, Inc. The Nuclear Verdict (Kanasky B, Speckart G), litigation consulting commentary on nuclear settlements and pre-mediation jury research.
- AM Best, Best’s Market Segment Report: Medical Professional Liability Underwriting Results Pressured by Evolving and Complex Landscape (May 13, 2025) (2024 was the MPL composite’s tenth consecutive year of underwriting losses; “claims severity continues to rise”); AM Best, Best’s Market Segment Report: Challenges Persist for the U.S. Medical Professional Liability Market (May 6, 2026) (underwriting loss of $712 million in 2025).